Alan of New South Wales has asked this question and mentioned that a member of his group has pointed out that Robert’s Rules may not be legal in Australia.

The legality is not the issue so much as the appropriateness of Robert’s Rules for Australia and New Zealand.

Robert’s Rules are in a book whose full title is “Robert’s Rules of Order Newly Revised – 10th Edition”. It is often referred to as “RONR”. It is a 700 page book and covers aspects of meetings in minute detail. The level of detail covered is such that in 30 years of consulting in Australia and New Zealand and Singapore, I have very rarely come across meetings that require the level of procedural detail which Robert’s uses.

I am conversant with the content of Robert’s Rules as a member of the American Institute of Parliamentarians (AIP) which teaches Robert’s Rules together with other American authorities. I attend workshops in the United States every couple of years to update my knowledge.

Robert’s is a great book for North American meetings. The terminology used is in many cases specifically North American and is never used in Australia, or more problematic, has a different meaning in Australia.

So while it is not illegal to use Robert’s Rules for meetings in Australia, it is inappropriate. There are much more appropriate books for Australia available such as the following:

General books on meeting procedure

Meeting Procedure Made Easy

By David Julian Price

Published by Cascade Publishing

Available at www.meetingsinstitute.com

Guide for Meetings and Organisations

By N.E. Renton

Published by the Law Book Company

Available at bookshops

Take the Chair

By David Price, Harold Luxton and Bill Smith

Published by Australian Rostrum

Available from Rostrum Western Australia

Books for Company Meetings

Company Meetings, What you need to know

By Greg Bateman

Published by Butterworths

Available at bookshops

Books for more legal and technical information

Joske’s Law and Procedure at Meetings in Australia

By Eilis S Magner

Published by The Law Book Company

Available in bookshops

Horsley’s Meetings. Procedure, Law and Practice

By A.D. Lang

Published by Butterworths

Available in bookshops

Please Note: The author accepts no responsibility for anything which occurs directly or indirectly as a result of using any of the suggestions or procedures detailed in this blog. All suggestions and procedures are provided in good faith as general guidelines only and should be used in conjunction with relevant legislation, constitutions, rules, laws, by-laws, and with reasonable judgement.

Related posts:

1. What are the main authorities or references for meeting procedure in Australia and New Zealand There are a number of books on meeting procedure in Australia and New Zealand. CAUTION: Your organisation may use a book called "Robert's Rules" (often referred to as RONR) - be careful as this is an American book which uses...
2. Books on Meeting Procedure for Australia and New Zealand Here is a list of books on meeting procedure for Australia and New Zealand. General books on meeting procedure Meeting Procedure Made Easy By David Julian Price Published by Cascade Publishing Available at www.meetingsinstitute.com Guide for Meetings and Organisations By...
3. Welcome to the Blog Here I will be commenting on issues which arise from clients and general issues relating to everything to do with meetings. You are welcome to submit questions or comments and the more questions we receive, the more useful the...
4. The terminolgy minefield – what do all these terms mean in meetings? The Terminology Minefield Here are some common terms that some people are not clear about. It is by no means an exhaustive list. An expanded list can be found at www.meetingsurvivalkit.com Absolute majority: The number of votes required to achieve...
5. Does a motion need to be seconded? This question is common and the answer is fairly simple. In Australia and New Zealand it is custom to have every motion seconded. Whether it is a requirement however depends on your constitution or governing rules. If your governing rules...