Peter has asked the following question:

How do minutes become confirmed if the persons present at the meeting when a decision was adopted are no longer in attendance?

This is a really common question and the answer sounds weird, but it is nevertheless the answer!

The scenario is that at meeting1 certain people are in attendance and the minutes are written.

At meeting 2, some (or possibly all) of the people who were at meeting 1, are absent.

The minutes of meeting1 are to be confirmed at meeting 2. Anyone can in fact move or second the confirmation motion and everyone present at meeting 2 can vote.

The issue is this Does meeting 2 accept that the minutes as presented are an accurate record?

The key word is accept

The question is not – Does meeting 2 know with certainty that the minutes are an accurate record?

So the confirmation of the minutes is really saying that in the opinion of the people at meeting 2, the minutes of meeting 1 are accurate.

By the way, just because a set of minutes is confirmed, that does mean they are set in stone. If at a later point an error or inaccuracy comes to light you can go back and amend any set of minutes but only with the approval of a meeting.

It all really comes down the faith the people have in the minute taker so always choose a good one!

I know it sounds weird but that;’s the answer folks!

Related posts:

1. How much do you record of what people say in minutes of meetings? This is an on-going issue for people who take minutes and people who attend meetings.  What do you record about what people say? Here is the Golden Rule of minute taking: Minutes are what is decided and what is done,...
2. Minutes are NOT a record of what people say! Don’t ask me why, but in my more than 25 years working with people on their meetings, dog clubs and volunteer fire brigades seem to have the most trouble with their meetings! I’ve had a query from a man in...
3. How do you deal with people who mumble or people who cannot be heard in meetings?   How do you deal with people who mumble or people who cannot be heard in meetings? You have to be assertive and ask them to speak up or tell the person in the chair that you cannot hear a...
4. Who should see the minutes before they are distributed? Alan of Victoria has asked this question because in his volunteer group, the chairman and the secretary insist on seeing the minutes which the minute secretary has prepared before they go to the other people at the meeting. This is...
5. Minutes of an AGM cannot be found Bon has asked the following question: What can you do if you are unable to locate the preceding AGM minutes due to poor record keeping and changeover of staff? The financial statements are available but the ensuing discussions are not...