A question has been received from John of Ballajura in WA.
We had a person who is unfinancial but used to be a member attend one of our meetings. The president let him speak but would not count his vote. What should the president have done? He has not been a member for a year and he acknowledged that he was no longer a member.
Since the person acknowledged that he was no longer a member, that clears up one issue – whether he was financial or not.
Technically, the president could have asked him to leave the meeting but in reality. most people would not do that, especially if it is the custom for the meetings to be “open” to visitors, members of the public, prospective members etc.
So having him there was probably not a problem.
The question is really twofold – should he have been allowed to speak, and should he be allowed to vote.
The second question is easy – he does not get a vote.
Whether he can speak is really up to the president, and ultimately the meeting. If he was constructive and courteous and reasonable when he spoke, most presidents would let him speak. If he was not, then the president can certainly deny him the right to speak.
If it is a controversial issue, then that potentially open the proverbial “can of worms”. It may be wise to let him speak, thereby dismissing the criticism that he was “silenced”. But, he may have views which are not held by the mainstream membership and letting him speak may inflame the situation.
It’s a judgement call and that’s why presidents and people who chair meetings need knowledge but much more important, wisdom.
Please Note: The author accepts no responsibility for anything which occurs directly or indirectly as a result of using any of the suggestions or procedures detailed in this blog. This is not, and should be taken as legal advice. All suggestions and procedures are provided in good faith as general guidelines only and should be used in conjunction with relevant legislation, constitutions, rules, laws, by-laws, and with reasonable judgement. If you are in any doubt, seek appropriate advice.
- When is a member no longer financial? When is a member no longer financial? This is a common question. I have seen legal advice which gives the following answer but you must not take this as advice for your situation – the following answer is general only,...
- Casting Votes – when and how to use them Casting votes is an issue that has come up recently with a client. They sound simple but there is a little bit behind them. Firstly, casting votes are sometimes called second votes. They occur when a vote is taken in...
- Can the president (or chair) move a motion at a meeting? Andrea from Koroop in Victoria, Australia has asked: ”Can the president move a motion at a meeting? What law is this held under?” The short answer is yes. The longer answer is that a wise chair will only move certain...
- Deliberative votes A deliberative vote is a vote given to a person because they are a member of the group. The term is usually applied to people who chair the meeting to draw a distinction between the vote they get as a...
- What are the main authorities or references for meeting procedure in Australia and New Zealand There are a number of books on meeting procedure in Australia and New Zealand. CAUTION: Your organisation may use a book called “Robert’s Rules” (often referred to as RONR) – be careful as this is an American book which uses...